JETS blog of our thoughts, experiences, reflections and resources with online and distance learning.
Wednesday, January 23, 2013
Distance Learning: How I Engage Students:
Vancouver students line up!
In my first Voices post, I reflected on my work with students around the world as an online teacher for JETS, our Israeli-based company. The technology is powerful, I said, but what fascinates me most about distance learning is the human reaction to these technology-supported events. I think there is a need, in today’s wired world, to connect to another person far away, living a different, yet somehow similar life.
Another major a-ha for me as an online teacher is the dynamic and potential for group involvement. When I describe what I do to people who are, shall we say, “not connected to the world of web culture,” they are amazed. “You mean the kids can see you and hear you? Don’t they get bored?”
Well, if all they did was listen to me teach, then yes, they would get bored. Wouldn’t you? Which is why I make sure that my classes do not involve lecturing. Obviously, there is discussion. But there is also much more. In fact, I am actually amazed at how much interaction there can be, not only intellectually but physically.
For example, I assigned students in Vancouver, Canada a project to research a site in Israel, share a photo, and state what occurred there 2000 years ago, and what is done there today. After each group of students presented, I gave them 60 seconds to organize themselves, representing their sites, in the correct geographical order; lining up accordingly, without any teacher assistance. A mass huddle and group discussion ensued. “Where is Metulla? Is it higher than the Golan Heights? Is Eilat beneath Be’er Sheva?’
The map of Israel hanging in the corner of their physical classroom, usually neglected, was frequently consulted. In 60 seconds, more or less, a group of very excited fourth graders queued up in front of the camera and happily shouted out the name of their city or town, in order. When I began teaching this group, there was little to no knowledge about Israel’s geography and history. After a few short weeks, how much had they learned — in engaging, stimulating ways!
Student work: Researching sites in Israel - the beach city of Herzliya (click to enlarge)
Online, every voice is heard
For older classes, technology often replaces physical movement (but not entirely! More on that another time). For example, online tools are often used as a key method of communication. Wikis replace whiteboards (and line-ups). The creation of online artifacts and student presentations encourages group work, and ensures that I hear from every student in the class. In a classroom discussion, typically, a few students dominate. In an online discussion, every voice is heard, from shy students and learning disabled ones, even ones with special needs, who might not ordinarily speak out.
There was one incident in a Los Angeles high school of a student who was pulled out of my class after a week. The school administrator explained that she was placed there by mistake. The student was autistic and the administration felt the dynamics of an online class would be too much for her. The course was blended: M, T, W were live video conferencing sessions and Thursday, they completed coursework online.
After a few days, the autistic student was back.
“What’s going on?” I asked the principal.
“Do you mind if she stays?” he asked. “She was placed in a regular class and she said it wasn’t nearly as interesting and stimulating as yours.”
I laughed. She stayed, and she taught us so much. She created beautiful, intelligent movies, PPTs, games, and songs. Her opinion shone through, and I often used her work as an example of excellence. Another shy student who sat in the back and hated to be called on had the most fabulous posts. But ask her to say the same things in class? Never. Online tools provide a level of comfort for students who do not want to be in the limelight. I realize that some of these strategies and web-based tools can be utilized in a traditional classroom setting. They are all the more appropriate for an online setting.
A final lesson learned: Creativity, planning, organization and follow-up are all skills I’ve had to hone in my role as an online teacher. I used these skills when I taught students face to face as well, but I’ve found that ‘winging a lesson’ was much more possible when we were all in the same physical room. I just can’t get away with that in my virtual world.
Travel has never been so easy
Personally, I love connecting. I find my job extremely rewarding, from listening to the opinions of students from all walks of life, to engaging students across many grades (4th-12th in fact) physically, intellectually and virtually. I enjoy my insta-travel with my large screen in my home office. Travel has never been so easy! I click my mouse, and boom: Jacksonville, Edmonton, Houston. I’ve asked educators who don’t interact with other students or locations why they choose not to. Sometimes they say ‘I don’t have time,’ or ‘it’s too much of a bother’ to connect to students or programs elsewhere. Perhaps more guidance can become available from tech staff and from teachers who have connected to other students online and who share their experiences.
[Can you imagine telling someone who has the means to travel 'not to bother?' ]
One aspect of the 21st century skill set involves developing global citizenship skills. Online learning offers a number of methods to develop these skills for our ever changing and connected world.
Online learning seems to me like a bike ride. The destination is the world. Each city is another spoke of the wheel. And the rider? Well, that’s up to you.
One’s destination is never a place, but a new way of seeing things. — Henry Miller
I teach online, through live video conferencing, from my home in Jerusalem to over 20 schools in the US, Canada and England. These schools contract with my company, JETS, for a number of educational courses on global Jewish issues, Israel education and culture, and Jewish Bible and history.
During my time as an online educator, I’ve used a variety of video conferencing platforms, such as Skype, Webex, Adobe ProConnect and Polycom video conferencing hardware. I have taught students in public schools, Catholic schools and Jewish Day Schools and complementary schools, live. Schools use projectors and microphones to ensure quality video and audio performance, the courses are completely interactive, and I have received very positive feedback.
Camel Rider: My daughter Hadas stars in our Ancient Israel videos.
But there is something that catches my eye each time I run a session: it’s the human reaction to these technology-supported events. My children often walk into my home studio and stare at my screen, not knowing if the people they see are in Memphis, Vancouver or London. At the other end, people (both teachers and adults) become very excited about the following:
• My eight-year old son walks in, holding his cat.You have a pet in Israel?
• My five-year old daughter comes to give me a hug in her pajamas. What time is it there, anyway?(Israel is 7 hours ahead of EST, and most of my classes are conducted at night in Israel).
• I share with students in Toronto how the students in Miami reacted to the very same question we are currently addressing: Why did people in ancient times choose to live in a cave?Toronto response: to get out of the cold. Miami response: to get out of the heat, a cave has built-in air conditioning!
These incidents are part of my everyday online teaching & learning life, and they help students feel connected.
Why choose online learning?
Being an online instructor, I am constantly answering questions from my peers in Israel. “Why would they want you to teach their students? Don’t they have teachers?” And I repeat what I’m sure many online instructors have stated before:
• Access an expert in the field.
• Share with your students a different point of view.
• Jewish and Catholic schools have a vested interest in learning about Israeli sites, history and culture from someone on the ground.
These are all valid points and I wave my flag for them every day. But underneath all that, I think there is a need, in today’s wired world, to connect to another person far away, living a different, yet somehow similar life. I love sharing in my students’ curiosity about my life, and I love learning about theirs.
For example: Archaeology is a huge topic in Israel. No highway can be dug, no hospital built, until the Israel Antiquities Authority goes in first and ensures that no ancient civilization is waiting to be uncovered. I wanted to share this idea during a distance learning session with some students in Miami who were studying Lifestyles in Ancient Israel. I suggested they dig up their backyards (they all have big backyards, of course, relative to the apartment city blocks in Jerusalem). “What do you think you will find?” I asked. Blank stares met my eyes.
Oops, wrong question, I tell myself. I’m originally from Southern California. I can reshape this question. I ask “how many of you have swimming pools in your backyard?” Every hand goes up. “Imagine a crew would come in and dig underneath your swimming pools — what do you think they would find?”
“Create a time capsule,” I suggest, “of what people would find in Miami.”
Students work in groups, tossing out answers, arguing among themselves. Rocks, animal bones, bricks, they propose.
“Now create a time capsule of what we find in Jerusalem!” After a few sessions together, students understand that the list will grow substantially: pottery shards, jewelry, weapons, skeletons, ancient seals and religious artifacts. Students realize how historical Israel is as a culture, how many nations have conquered this region and lived here, and how much there is to gain from studying ancient and modern Israel. When I show them a video of my daughter digging up a jug on an ancient dusty road, the idea comes to life. Another connection has been made. “Did your daughter really find that jug?” they ask. I smile. “What do you think?”
Here’s the video – it’s the introduction to our program about children’s lifestyles in ancient Israel.
My partners and I put many hours of preparation into each of our lessons. Slides, questions, activities and videos are carefully planned and plotted. I get great feedback, don’t get me wrong. But when my online students joyfully greet my children, or watch the sky darken behind me as they set off to lunch, I realize that they are learning, reflecting, internalizing — educating themselves about things I never planned. I marvel that they create these connections independently and revel in the wonderful, wide world in which we live.